Electric Vehicles (EVs) are revolutionizing the automobile market in the wake of rising fossil fuel prices. TATA has made significant strides in the EV sector, with the successful sales of the Nexon EV and Tiago EV. However, EVs generally have a higher price tag compared to traditional fossil fuel vehicles. Another player in the EV market is MG, with their micro EV called the Comet EV. Now let’s delve into a detailed comparison between the MG Comet EV and the TATA Tiago EV.
Oil-Cooled vs Liquid-Cooled Engines: Which is the Best Option?”
Follow us on Twitter, Telegram and Google News
Power and Transmission
The MG Comet EV is equipped with a 17.3 kWh battery capacity, while the TATA Tiago EV boasts a larger 24 kWh battery capacity. In terms of performance, the MG Comet EV generates 110 Nm torque and a maximum power of 41.42 bhp, while the TATA Tiago EV produces 114 Nm torque and an impressive 73.75 bhp power, which is quite remarkable.
Battery Capacity
One notable drawback of the MG Comet EV is its lack of fast charging capability, which translates to a lengthy 7-hour charging time for a full battery. In real-world conditions, the MG Comet EV can cover around 180 km considering traffic and other factors, while MG claims a range of 230 km on a full battery charge.
On the other hand, the TATA Tiago EV offers excellent fast charging capability, taking just about 58 min to fully charge the battery. It may provide a range of 280 to 290 km on the road, considering traffic and other factors, while TATA claims a range of 315 km on a single charge.
Warranty
When it comes to warranties, MG offers a 3-year comprehensive warranty on the battery, whereas TATA provides an impressive 8-year warranty on the battery. This makes TATA Tiago EV even more enticing. Both EVs come equipped with electric steering. The MG Comet, being a micro EV, has a smaller turning radius of 4.2 m, while the Tiago EV requires 5.1 m. Both EVs have disc brakes at the front and drum brakes at the rear.
Dimensions
In terms of dimensions, the MG Comet measures approximately 2971 mm in length, 1505 mm in width, and 1640 mm in height, which classifies it as a micro EV. Although MG claims it is a 4-seater EV, it might not be comfortable for four people. On the other hand, the Tiago EV offers a length of 3769 mm, a width of 1677 mm, and a height of 1536 mm. The Tiago can comfortably accommodate four people on long rides and even five people on shorter trips. The Comet EV lacks any boot space, while the Tiago EV provides 240 liters of boot space.
In terms of tires, the MG Comet features a smaller size of 145/70 R12 with a 12-inch wheel size, while the Tiago EV is equipped with 175/65 R14 tires and a 14-inch wheel size. Both EVs come with tubeless tires.
Safety Rating and Features
Both EVs come with power steering, power windows, and power boot features. The Tiago EV has the added advantage of automatic climate control, which the Comet EV lacks. Voice control is available in both vehicles. Moving on to safety, both EVs are equipped with dual airbags. MG has not disclosed the Global NCAP safety rating for the Comet EV, while the Tiago EV has received a 4-star safety rating.
Price
MG Comet EV’s ex-showroom price starts from INR 7,98,000 and goes up to INR 9,98,000. Tata Tiago EV’s ex-showroom price starts from INR 8,69,000 and goes up to INR 12,00,000.
Conclusion
When comparing the TATA Tiago EV and the MG Comet EV, it becomes evident that the Tiago EV outshines its counterpart in various aspects, making it a more favorable choice. The Tiago EV boasts a larger battery capacity, providing enhanced power and torque for a better driving experience. Additionally, its charging speed is faster, resulting in less time spent waiting to recharge. With a longer range, the Tiago EV enables drivers to cover more distance on a single charge, making it suitable for extended journeys. Moreover, the Tiago EV offers a more spacious interior and additional boot space, providing greater comfort and convenience.
On the other hand, the MG Comet EV falls short in several areas. It is primarily suitable for short, day-to-day rides and lacks comfort on uneven or poor road conditions. Furthermore, the Comet EV has a shorter battery warranty, which may be seen as a drawback, particularly considering the substantial investment of around 8 lakhs INR. In contrast, the Tiago EV provides a feature-rich, premium interior, ensuring both comfort and convenience for both short and long travels.
